I've enabled comment reply by email setting but I still have a little problem.
Everytime I get an email notification that a comment is held for moderation (comment from someone with no-previously-approved-comment) and want to reply it from my inbox I have to do several steps:
1. approve that comment (by clicking the link in the mail, which will open wp admin page in a new tab)
2. wait another email notifying me the new comment has "appeared"
3. then reply to that email (which I think is not "reply by email" anymore because the admin page already opened in another tab)
I can't reply to the first email because it sent from [email redacted] and doesn't specify a different reply-to address like the second email.
Anybody know how to approving & replying a comment AT ONCE without doing all the steps above? I looked at the support page but I can't find a way for this.
Btw, my blog is set like this:
E-mail me whenever Anyone posts a comment
E-mail me whenever A comment is held for moderation
Before a comment appears Comment author must have a previously approved comment
Enable sending comment replies via email
The blog I need help with is egomaniac.wordpress.com.