I am continuing to get the wordpress generated icons displaying for the users. In the admin panel though, I can see the correct icons in the user profile and general settings.
I have added both days ago (Jan 1). Cleaned out my internet cache files, cookies, and history. I have logged out and logged in. I have closed the browser and re-opened. And then finally, I have rebooted the computer a few times. I realize it takes about a day to change, but this seems a bit long.