I am having the same problem as above with the Good Man Project – I didn’t add it to my Reader list and can’t seem to get rid of it. It doesn’t show up in my “Edit List” to be removed, and the Good Man Project site doesn’t have an “unfollow” option.
Has a solution been found for clearing away this pesky thing? Many thanks!
timethief – Sure! There was something wrong with the structure of the feed URL from the self-hosted site, through which the subscribers originally signed up. It had an extra parameter in the query string at the end that should not have been there. That malformed URL was preventing the feed from showing up in some users’ subscription lists and also stopping it from being deletable in any way.
As for how some folks got added to a feed they say they never intended to subscribe to – that part remains a mystery for now.