Editing comments has become a bit more tedious

  • Author
    Posts
  • #111664

    This is not a big deal but… Occasionally I want to go back and add something to my own comment, or perhaps to clean up some formatting problem in a visitor’s comment. As of the last week or two I notice when I do this that when I click “edit” the editor that comes up with the comment contains some html code that I don’t recall seeing in the past — mostly <p>, </br>, etc. But in addition, the paragraphs are shoved together such that I have to manually hit the “enter” key at the start of every paragraph to separate them so the appropriate spaces appear between them after I edit. It’s a minor inconvenience, but it did not happen previously. i.e., previously the paragraphs stayed correctly positioned, and I could just do my edit and hit the button and be done with it. What has changed?

    (Apologies if this has come up already. A quick search didn’t turn it up.)

    #112086

    dirkgently
    Member

    The code showing up simply tells you that you’re in code view. <p> is a paragraph with everything between `</p> and
    </p>listed as one single paragraph.</br>is a line break. You may spot others likewhich is around bold text. Simple rule of thumb when dealing with html code......always close the tags. By this I mean if you start a new paragraph with a<p>always remember to end it with</p>`
    Also think of it as circles
    with the closing tags in reverse order`

    Things look very different in code view to the way they will be displayed on the site too, so don’t bother trying to arrange the look visually in code view, as long as the right html tags are applied in the right order….it’ll display fine on the site.

    #112087

    dirkgently
    Member

    OMG editing comments in the forums which include the backticks and code is a NIGHTMARE!!!! It gets stripped out, leaving you against the clock trying to reassemble what you had, re-inserting what you’d already written and it’d already accepted BEFORE you can make the slight alteration you intended. It is VERY difficult when the removal of backticks throws it all off……so my first post above is not quite how I intended, but I refuse to sit and fight with an unwieldy system just to get it better.

    Just thought I’d mention to anyone offering help involving the ` backticks……get it right first time, otherwise it’s a mess.

    #112092

    I’ve noticed the same problems with editing comments, in particular with the stripping out of all line breaks between the paragraphs. It seems to strip out p and br tags progressively each time you edit.

    Until a month or so ago, that wasn’t the case.

    #112096

    dirkgently
    Member

    Yeah, I only wanted to add on the last paragraph in an edit, and found it had fu#ked up the rest….so I tried to remake what I’d just done as best as I could knowing that when the clock ticked over it’d refuse to accept an edit. As a result my answer looks confusing and probably won’t help as much.

    At the moment I’ve decided not to bother fighting it, and let any questions that need the backticks be answered by those paid to deal with the system…unless it changes to stop hindering us…..and NO I will not be checking it again and again to see if it’s changed.

    #112097

    boles
    Member

    Several months ago we had the same problem with editing comments. A real nightmare.

    Then it was fixed.

    Now it’s broken again. The nightmare returns.

    #112099

    timethief
    Member

    @boles
    I remember the time to which you refer. Have you reported this to staff?

    #112104

    Okay, so I see others are having the problem. I could be wrong in my memory that the code didn’t used to show up when editing comments (unless one was manually inserting code). The part that’s the problem is the stuff like the stripping out of line breaks between paragraphs.

    #112105

    timethief
    Member

    Just to be sure. Did you try
    <br />
    and
    &nbsp;

    #112107

    dirkgently
    Member

    The forums are different from our individual blogs. They have different rules on what is accepted. Here you have to type any html code you want to include and you’re stuck with a visual editor without even the luxury of BOLD, ITALIC etc options….just a line of text explaining what markup is allowed and how.

    In our blogs we have a choice of a visual editor like this or a code editor which I personally prefer. This is commenting on another blog which is extremely limited.

    Some code will be stripped for security reasons in your blog, while some will reformat itself to fit the theme you’re using and have itself compatible with the stylesheet. I hate DIV tags but the wordpress themes seem to be rather obsessed with using them….it’s a nightmare to keep fighting against that….as it takes it upon itself to throw away all the stuff I’ve chosen to edit, and replace it with DIV tags….which throws out all the formatting.

    #112108

    timethief
    Member

    @everyone
    If you are experiencing the problem outlined above then please send in a feedback to staff including as much information as possible.

    #112113

    knoizki
    Member

    I’m not surprised by this, every weekend, we always see changes here and there and before you know it, things will eventually look better – never fear, just sit back and relax, the admins are probably upgrading the system again. :)

    #112118

    Dirk, just to clarify, on comments on our blogs I think the only choice we get is the code editor. I usually keep the visual editor turned on as the default for posts (then go back and forth between editors, depending), but have never seen it as an option for comments. Am I missing a toggle somewhere? In any case, the code editor used not to strip out breaks between paragraphs as it has for the last week or two.

    As I said, it’s a minor thing to me.

    [EDIT] By the way, I just tested it, and the comment editor here on the forum is not stripping them out either. Nor does paragraph or line break code etc. even show up in it when you go to edit. This is how comment editing used to behave on our blogs.

    #112119

    dirkgently
    Member

    Yeah sorry, I meant the code editor just as you see in the forums. The visual one has the buttons. I knew what I meant, just got it mixed up a little. It means that when you post in here, or a comment on a blog you have to manually add any code you want without any buttons to make it easy or you can prepare your comments in an html editor beforehand, then copy and paste the code over.

    #112213

    sangild
    Member

    This IS a big deal. Whenever I want to edit a comment I enter the “nightmare”, as someone has called it. In order to get a proper edited version one has to manually delete ALL codes and reinsert them again in order to avoid typographic errors. I just (again) spent 20 minutes making a small correction to a comment. It should have taken 20 seconds.

    This is not about people not understanding the codes. This is a bug and it should be fixed.

    Details: It ignores paragraph spacing, links, italics and other codes that worked perfectly before editing. Sometimes it shows the code as text, sometimes it ignores it completely. Sometimes the text is an inexplicable mess after adding a minor change.

    #112214

    timethief
    Member

    @sangild
    Volunteers answering questions on the forum do not have backend access to blogs and cannot “fix bugs”. If you think one exists then the way to go is copying and pasting all your relevant information above into a feedback and sending it to staff.

    #112215

    sangild
    Member

    Sure, I just thought it needed the right label here…;-)

    #112218

    yexxle
    Member

    I was just going to post the same complaint. What’s worse is editing a blog entry comment that has html in it. Every html special character is being double-escaped and you wind up with nasty-looking < and > everywhere. To the dev team, I would suggest taking out the htmlspecialchars() or htmlentities() call that is being applied to the comment text before it is displayed in the edit text box: obviously the html escaping has already been applied once.

    #112229

    feartheseeds
    Member

    I’ve noticed the paragraph fomatting going screwy, but I just took a look and the code people input on their own (bold, etc) also gets messed up when I edit a comment… has there been any response to anyone’s “feedback” or are we waiting?

    #112230

    timethief
    Member

    @ feartheseeds
    Volunteers answering questions on the forum do not have backend access to blogs and cannot “fix bugs”. If you think one exists then the way to go is copying and pasting all your relevant information above into a feedback and sending it to staff. Then waiting for staff to get back to you is what you must do.

    As Mark lives in the UK and there is a substantial time difference, and as there are probably matters of higher priority for him to attend to prior to dealing with yours, I suggest that you exercise some patience.

The topic ‘Editing comments has become a bit more tedious’ is closed to new replies.