increase number of recent comments shown?

  • Author
    Posts
  • #19517

    isaiah543
    Member

    Is there anyway to show more than 5 recent comments in the recent comment widget?

    #19638

    timethief
    Member

    I don’t believe so. I think it may be set by default.

    #19644

    vivianpaige
    Member

    Nope. But if enough of us send it in thru feedback, perhaps they will change it :)

    #19645

    timethief
    Member

    I don’t get it so I’m not inclined to jump on this bandwagon. All comments corresponding with all posts are just a click away if any reader wants to read them. That’s why I don’t get why increasing the number of comments grouped together in the sideabar is desirable. Please explain what useful purpose a lengthy string of them in the sidebar serves. Is it a vanity thing or what?

    #19647

    vivianpaige
    Member

    I think both Recent Posts and Recent Comments should be configurable by the user, like we can do with the number posts on the page. Right now, the number of Recent Posts is 10 while the number of Recent Comments is only 5. The problem for me is not vanity – instead, people are commenting on different posts and I would like more of them to show, especially since sometimes the posts they are commenting on are no longer on the front page.

    There is no way for visitors to know that older posts have recent comments on them.

    The other thing is that I try to comment back to my readers and what ends up happening is that the Recent Comments are sometimes all just my responses.

    If the widget is fixed, it should at least be 10 comments. 5 is just too few.

    #19648

    timethief
    Member

    I understand you now. It’s actually an “on the front page issue”. The fact that we do answer those who comment means that we ourselves could be accounting for the whole five comments being shown on the front page in the sidebar in any given day. However, if a reader clicks on any one of those comments that are shown whether or not it’s our comment he or she will find all the other comments relating to that post so that’s not a huge problem. Anyone who’s following the post will follow the comments.

    The problem arises when folks comment on posts that are not on the front page and we comment in response because their comments can quickly disappear. And the casual reader may not find their way to the posts with comments that do not appear on the first page.

    If it’s an issue for you now I think there are there are two work around possibilities.
    (1) You could choose to use a sidebar widget to account for five more commenters names and post titles linked to the actual comments on the post.
    (2) Alternatively, establishing a page that links to the actual comments on the post could achieve the same purpose.

    #19649

    vivianpaige
    Member

    Um – your #1 IS the comments sidebar widget. There is only one of those widgets available so there is no way to get 5 *more*. (Regulus doesn’t have comments built into the theme.)

    Choice #2 is unworkable because it requires too much upkeep for me. I just hope that the folks here at WordPress make the Recent Posts and Recent Comments widgets configurable – like the RSS widget.

    #19663

    timethief
    Member

    Vivian you misunderstood my number (1). Yes, we do already have an automatically updating recent comments widget. Yes, I understand what you want is for its capacity to display comment links on the front page in the sidebar doubled.

    What I was suggesting was that you could use a text widget to create your own “recent comments” to hold as many comment links on the front page in the sidebar as you want. While it’s true that it wouldn’t automatically update it’s also true that you’d only have to enter a single line of text for each comment link (eg. ralph on voting procedure).

    My number (2) suggestion is the same thing – create a page and enter one line of text for each comment link eg. ralph on voting procedure).

    The whole point of suggesting work arounds to you was the timeframe thing – if it’s an issue for you now, you could address it now, while you’re waiting. That’s what I was suggesting.:)

    #19664

    knoizki
    Member

    I don’t know why easy questions gets a very difficult answers. What the person who asked for this is to have 10 Comments appeared on the widget sidebar. If it’s addable or just 5. Period.

    As to this Comment thingy, I asked for the same purpose, can wordpress.com add a widget for Most Commented Posts? I know not everything is difficult but it can be possible.

    Thank you.

    #19667

    timethief
    Member

    knoizki – I’m surprised that an old hand at blogging like you, who has already sent a request for a “most commented posts” widget and which is a different subject than the one in this thread, hasn’t already devised a workaround, while you’re ranging around waiting.

    #19710

    drmike
    Member

    Hmmm, I thought it was 10 as well. I’m sending in a Feedback as well.

    At least make it and the Recent Posts widget chooseable.

    #19786

    vivianpaige
    Member

    Thanks for your support, drmike!

    #19839

    drmike
    Member

    Feedback sent. (Thanks, TT)

    #20186

    vivianpaige
    Member

    I wanted to bump this up. We’ve had quite a few enhancements to WP lately which, while nice, are just not as useful to meas a user-configurable recent comments widget would be. At the minimum, an increase from 5 to 10 would be helpful.

    #20187

    timethief
    Member

    Good idea.:)

    #20195

    britgirl
    Member

    Agree, if we could have more comments showing in the sidebar that would be great. Much needed.

    #20199

    rollmops
    Member

    I would like to have this widget also configurable, or just 10 instead of 5. Sent in Feedback also.

    #20200

    cyanee
    Member

    yup! a really useful feature to show more comments… like 10
    sent in feedback too :)

    #20204

    alunsalt
    Member

    What you can do is subscribe to your own comments RSS feed to get up to 10 comments. It doesn’t look as neat, but it is workable. I’ve put it up on my page at http://archaeoastronomy.co.uk/ as an example beneath Recent Posts.

    #20205

    eclecticgeek
    Member

    Just made the change. I like it. Thanks for the good idea alunsalt. I’ll use this until the Comments widget is changed (pretty please). :-)

The topic ‘increase number of recent comments shown?’ is closed to new replies.