Ok this is the problem: I use multiple avatars on Gravatar each corresponding with a different e-mail address. I created the Gravatar account so I could post comments on Memebase and change my Avatar by simply entering a different e-mail address. Then one day I woke up and suddenly discovered that automatically a WordPress account had been created for me. Now I’m unable to post comments with any of my e-mail addresses without logging into wordpress, meaning I can only use one (the main) avatar. Now I want a way to untangle my Gravatar Account from my WordPress account, get rid of it altogether or anything remotely helpful.
I thank everyone who even read this post for paying attention to my problem and everyone who posts a suggestion twice as much.